Throughout my several visits to my VIPS tutoring classroom (as well as through my own classroom experience), I have witnessed several threats by a teacher to call a misbehaving student's parents. In most of these calls the topic of conversation revolves around a negative topic--i.e. misbehaving in class or receiving a bad grade on an exam. Similarly, parents only seem to contact a teacher/professor in order to defend their child. This forms a very negatively based parent-teacher relationship when, realistically, the parent should be welcomed into the classroom community and vise versa.
Dennis Carlson comments on three types of community--communities of interest, "father knows best", and a multicultural community--in his article "Gayness, Multicultural Education, and Community". His communities of interest model displays a society where people are separated into, and categorized by, groups defined by interests (race, orientation, etc.). The father knows best model highlights the idea that there is a sense of necessary superiority and privilege among deserving members of society. It seems to regress to the once dominant belief that it was "the white man's burden" to educate the less fortunate and less knowledgeable black race. Finally, the multicultural community provides a domain for a society to build around difference and diversity. It allows for interest groups to form within it; however, they only exist within a broader sense of cultural community.
The concepts exhibited within Carlson's article can be broadly applied to the sense of community--or lack thereof--within schools and their student households. I feel that commonly this relationship is better defined by the "father knows best" model than by anything else. Often times there is more conflict than collaboration when parents and teachers get together to solve student based issues. Both the teacher and the parent seem to think they know what is best for their student/child. Occasionally, this sort of debate will lead to a discussion of assigning blame rather than one geared toward problem resolution. Parent-teacher conferences can regularly head down one of two roads. The first heads down a path where the parent gets angered, defends the child, and blames the educator for the students shortcomings. In the second case the parent does the exact opposite and blames the child completely for their problems in school. As is true with many things in life, this issue is not always so black and white.
The concepts and principles that constitute a "multicultural community" can still be applied without regard to race, gender, or orientation. Communal divisions can also be drawn by discrepancies on beliefs and decisions, which brings us back to the issue at hand. We know the current state and we know the ends we wish to reach, but what must be done to bring society to those ends? Communication is the answer. It is no coincidence that communication and community possess the same root word; one supports the other. For example, a monthly newsletter, programs like mygradebook.com, and perhaps an occasional phone call to dictate student improvement, will help communicate the classroom environment and individual student standing from school to the home. Similarly, if there is an appropriate place for parents to inform the teacher that, for example, the student's best friend just moved away or that the student has an important religious day to prepare for, it promotes a stronger sense of community, understanding and solidarity.
As the walls supported by these misunderstanding begin to fall, parents and teachers will realize that, while they may be quite different, their goals (the well-being of the student) are more congruent than they initially thought. They ability for these interest groups to exist as consciously different entities within a larger, commonly motivated, community is what Carlson's multicultural community is all about.
Hi Nick,
ReplyDeleteI never applied Carlson's perspectives of community to the issue of teacher/parent interaction. It is brilliant.
Thank you,
Dr. August
I completely agree that by only calling parents for the bad things their children do is a start to a negative relationship. Calls to parents shouldn't be made only when a child is misbehaving. Parents might like teachers more if they were updated on how well their child is doing, and not just that their child is misbehaving.
ReplyDeleteYou also make a very good point about the "father knows best" model when you apply it to the relationship between teachers and parents. I think that when the parent and teacher are adamant that they know whats best for the child, nothing good can come of it. Teachers and parents very obviously know the children differently. They should work together in harmony in order to make the childs education the best it can be in many aspects.