The interesting thing about biases is the nature of their existence. Biases are not always realized to be in existence by a given individual. For example, certain people will argue that because they have friends that are African-American they can easily be categorized as "non-racist". This is naive view does not, however, disprove the fact that everyone retains some generalized stereotypes regarding members of different races. These "disconscious biases" exist more prevalently in modern society than one might think.
In "Subtle Versus Overt Racism" David Shipler questions why there are only 300 black pilots in an Air Force of nearly 15,000. The answer, perhaps, lies in the age old assumption that fair skinned peoples are inherently more intelligent than people of color. One example provided by Shipler delves into a meticulous assessment of flight exams--which, if passed, would provided students entry to the society of Air Force pilots. It is argued that the possibility of the aforementioned bias against non-whites may have a very real effect on the number of minorities that pass the test.
To elaborate, a theory has been posed that questions the legitimacy of the decisions made during flight assessments. For example, during the exam it is the duty of the flight instructor--who is usually white--to make swift decisions on when to take control of the aircraft if the trainee's operation is deemed "dangerous". This issue here is due to this disconscious bias, the instructor may be hasty in this split second decision when the trainee is of color--more specifically, hastier than he would have been with a white applicant.
With that in mind, how do we fix this? Many professionals would assert that diversity is our saving grace. Allen Johnson would argue otherwise. In his eyes, difference is not the problem and diversity is not the solution. The source of the problem noted in the anecdote expressed above is rooted in a system of oppression. His argument attests that until the flow of this ongoing system is disrupted, these sorts of discrimination will continue to exist in present and future societies. He proclaims that "our house is on fire"; we need to take action now.
This sort of oppression simply cannot exist in the classroom. It promotes marginalization and a progression toward the "cooling out process", but more importantly it allows for the continued survival of a system that allows such behavior. True, these "non-racists" may not actively take part in hate crimes; however, by not acting against it they are allowing such actions to continue. Simply put, if you are not part of the solution, you are part of the problem.
Hi Nick,
ReplyDeleteWhat a sophisticated discussion of the issue of bias. I am not familiar with Shipler's work. It is a perfect example of Johnson's point.
Bravo,
Dr. August
I'd never heard of "disconscious bias" before this class, but once I had, I was shocked at how many people had them. Many people who say they are not racist do indeed have this bias, and I completely agree with you about Johnson's point. If they don't fight it or rebel against it, these people ARE part of the problem. I think you really stated that point quite well.
ReplyDeleteReading this though, I also think about Dennis Carlson, who believes that differences need to be acknowledged and understood as varied. One man who is black is not defined by his skin color, just like a lesbian is not defined by her sexual orientation. The flight instructor may be making a split-second choice and end up picking the white trainee, but he is not thinking deeper than skin color. A white person doesn't have any extra skill than a black person, and the flight instructor, by basing his opinion on his own disconscious bias, may end up with a lesser trainee.